Key Paths

  • A meat-based burger has become a popular option for many families.
  • While both beef tenderloin and traditional beef burger proteins are offered, there are some differences in the specific ingredients of each.
  • Both options can be part of a overall healthy diet.

In the past, those who wanted to eat more plant-based proteins, such as lentils, soybeans, and almonds, were relying on unprofitable choices. But now the options have grown from soybeans to meatless hot dogs, “chicken” earrings, and tofurs. Beyond the meat and the impossible burgers are the solution for people who crave a burger but don’t want to eat a lot of meat.

But a vegetarian-based burger is not as nutritious as a burger, according to a new study.

Made from ingredients such as pea protein, bean curd protein, and / or wheat protein, these “burgers” hold fists in the protein compartment. Ingredients, such as beet extract, are added to the mixture to make the beef burger red. Sources of fat and vitamins have also been added.

So, like beef burgers, meat substitutes are high in protein, fat and soy and gluten-free. But unlike meat burgers, burger contains sodium. They are cholesterol free and contain fiber, but there are two characteristics that beef burgers do not require.

This research is important because it answers the question most of us have: Can designed food products look like real, completely ‘natural’ foods? The Bulls Association says to Saul. ”

So, although plant-based meat options and beef seem to offer the same amount of protein, “they can’t really change their diet when you consider the extended dietary profile,” says study author Stephen van Willett, PhD, Ph.D. He tells him.

“Our data do not mean that you have to eat meat or that meat is more nutritious,” says Van Wilt. Nor does it mean that one is healthier than the other. ”

A July study was published in the journal Scientific reports.

How different are beef and beef alternatives burgers?

Beef burgers and beef alternatives can both be satisfying. But they cannot be compared in diet.

Of course, the source of protein is very different: one is a single ingredient (beef) and the other is a combination of plant-based proteins.

But there are other dietary differences that should not be overlooked.

“In the field of nutrition science, our understanding of the impact of diet on our health is mainly focused on the nutrients that are normally found in the nutrition facts panels such as calories, protein, sugar, fats and vitamins and minerals,” said Van Wilt. . Although this knowledge is important to understand how it affects health and disease, these diets represent only a small fraction of the 26,000 metabolites in food, many of which have reported health effects but are not understood to be present in food. Sources. ”

One of the objectives of this study is to “determine how similar or different beef and vegan vegetarian meat alternatives are, in particular, their nutritional facts panels suggest that nutritional supplements may be available.”

Van Wilt and his colleagues compared the nutritional content of 18 plant-based meats and 18 grass-fed cattle using a method called metabolism. And while the dietary labels on the reviewed samples looked the same, there were some differences in dietary content when evaluating the ingredients that were not listed.

Twenty-two metabolites have been found in meat, including DHA, omega-3 fatty acids, niacinamide (vitamin B3), and certain antimicrobials. In addition, 51 metabolites have been found in beef, compared to plant-based meat alternatives.

On the other hand, only 31 metabolites are found in plant-based meat alternatives, including vitamin C and certain antioxidants.

Van Wilt added: “The big picture of our work is that considering the protein content of the diet as a balanced or variant diet reduces the amount of other nutrients in the diet.” Although they are all rich in protein, eggs are not the same as peanut butter and soy burger. In fact, in addition to protein, all of these can be part and parcel of a healthy diet.

What does this mean for you?

Beef alternative burgers are not as nutritious as meat burgers and choosing an alternative does not necessarily mean a “healthy” choice. You should try to include a variety of mixed proteins in your diet.

Which is better?

The results of this study show that plant-based burgers are not a perfect “swap” for each other, and each offers a unique combination of ingredients.

“This study is a big reminder that we need protein diversity in your diet, because each protein diet contains hundreds of different nutrients.

“To get a lot of different nutrients, look at a flexible diet with a mixed mix of animal-based protein and whole-grain protein, such as beans, lentils, and thyme, an excellent diet made from roasted whole soy,” Blatter added.

And if you are worried that if you choose one burger over the other, you will have dietary gaps. Them, especially during adolescence. Total nutritional quality will be very important to determine the health effects of individual foods.